7 Best Griddles for Kenmore Gas Grill That Cook Like a Dream

You’ve invested in a quality Kenmore gas grill, but you’re not getting the cooking performance you want. Standard grates just don’t cut it for certain foods—delicate proteins, vegetables, and breakfast items slip through the cracks. The right griddle transforms your grill’s capabilities entirely. We’ll show you which models deliver restaurant-quality results and why they’re worth the investment.

Quick Overview

• Cast iron griddles distribute heat evenly, delivering consistent cooking results across the entire surface without hot spots.
• Nonstick coatings simplify cleanup and maintenance, making post-cooking tasks quick and effortless compared to bare metal surfaces.
• Proper sizing ensures seamless compatibility with your specific Kenmore gas grill model for optimal fit and performance.
• Reinforced support structures and thick materials resist warping under intense heat, ensuring long-term durability and reliability.
• Built-in grease troughs and detachable handles provide convenient draining and easy transport for practical everyday use.

More Details on Our Top Picks

1. Uniflasy Nonstick Griddle for Gas Grills (25″ x 16″)

   [affimg asin=”B0B17GV57J” size=”large”]

   Best Large Capacity

   View Latest Price

   If you’re looking to expand your Kenmore grill’s versatility, the Uniflasy Nonstick Griddle delivers a spacious 25″ x 16″ cooking surface that won’t warp under uneven heat. This heavy-duty griddle features a durable nonstick coating that simplifies cleanup while accommodating everything from breakfast pancakes to dinner proteins. High bar sides prevent grease splatter and assist with flipping smaller foods like shrimp and mushrooms. The polished edges keep your hands safe during handling, and integrated handles enable easy repositioning. Its universal design fits most gas grills, including various Kenmore models. Just remember to heat the griddle gradually and evenly across its entire surface to maintain its structural integrity.

   • Material Type:Nonstick coated metal
   • Cooking Surface Design:Flat griddle with high bar sides
   • Dimensions:25 x 16 inches
   • Heat Distribution:Hollowed out side panels for even airflow
   • Portability Features:Handle for easy movement and carrying
   • Cleaning & Maintenance:Nonstick coating for easy cleaning
   • Additional Feature:Universal fit multiple grill brands
   • Additional Feature:High bar sides for flipping
   • Additional Feature:Gradual heating prevents warping

2. Lodge Cast Iron Reversible Grill/Griddle 9.5×16.75

   [affimg asin=”B002CMLTXG” size=”large”]

   Best Reversible Design

   View Latest Price

   The Lodge Cast Iron Reversible Grill/Griddle is your ideal choice when you’re seeking versatility beyond your Kenmore gas grill. This pre-seasoned 9.5 x 16.75-inch cooking surface features both flat and ribbed sides, letting you switch between griddle and grill functionality effortlessly. You’ll appreciate its heavy-duty construction and even heat distribution, which work seamlessly on stovetops, grills, or campfires. Made in the USA by the Lodge family since 1896, it’s crafted from iron and oil—completely PFAS-free and non-toxic. The double-burner size provides ample cooking space, and its compatibility with any cooktop, including induction, makes it remarkably adaptable for your cooking needs.

   • Material Type:Pre-seasoned cast iron
   • Cooking Surface Design:Reversible (flat griddle and ribbed grill)
   • Dimensions:9.5 x 16.75 inches
   • Heat Distribution:Even heat distribution and retention
   • Portability Features:No built-in handles (cast iron style)
   • Cleaning & Maintenance:Cast iron seasoning requires maintenance
   • Additional Feature:Reversible flat & ribbed sides
   • Additional Feature:Induction cooktop compatible
   • Additional Feature:Made in USA since 1896

3. Utheer 25″ Cast Iron Griddle for Grills

   [affimg asin=”B09Z6K4SSJ” size=”large”]

   Best Cast Iron Quality

   View Latest Price

   For those seeking a versatile griddle that transforms their Kenmore gas grill into a complete outdoor cooking station, Utheer’s 25″ cast iron option delivers exceptional performance. The pre-seasoned 25″ x 16″ surface fits most grills universally and features reinforced support ridges that distribute heat evenly, preventing warping during high-temperature cooking. Detachable side handles make lifting and storage effortless, while the built-in grease trough simplifies cleanup. You’ll cook everything from pancakes and eggs to steaks and vegetables with consistent results. The durable nonstick coating and polished edges guarantee safe, scratch-free use. Preheat before oiling for peak nonstick performance, and you’re ready to impress crowds or feed your family with restaurant-quality outdoor meals.

   • Material Type:Pre-seasoned nonstick cast iron
   • Cooking Surface Design:Flat griddle with grease trough
   • Dimensions:25 x 16 inches
   • Heat Distribution:Reinforced base with three support ridges
   • Portability Features:Detachable side handles for easy lifting
   • Cleaning & Maintenance:Nonstick coating with built-in grease trough
   • Additional Feature:Three support ridges for stability
   • Additional Feature:Built-in grease trough
   • Additional Feature:Detachable side handles

4. Utheer Nonstick Cast Iron Griddle for Gas Grill

   [affimg asin=”B09Z6HGKKK” size=”large”]

   Best Compact Option

   View Latest Price

   Utheer’s nonstick cast iron griddle delivers versatile cooking performance for anyone seeking to expand their gas grill’s capabilities beyond traditional grilling. At 17 by 13 inches, this rectangular griddle fits most gas grills and handles breakfast staples like pancakes alongside dinner proteins like steaks and seafood. You’ll appreciate the premium nonstick coating that’s easy to clean and safe for your family. Reinforced support ridges guarantee stable, even heat distribution, while detachable handles make transport effortless. The integrated grease trough prevents flare-ups, and polished edges keep your hands scratch-free. With a 4.4-star rating and #3 ranking in grill griddles, you’re investing in proven quality.

   • Material Type:Nonstick coated cast iron
   • Cooking Surface Design:Flat griddle with grease trough
   • Dimensions:17 x 13 inches
   • Heat Distribution:Reinforced support ridges for uniform heat
   • Portability Features:Detachable handles for carrying and storage
   • Cleaning & Maintenance:Easy-clean nonstick coating, not dishwasher safe
   • Additional Feature:Reinforced support ridges for stability
   • Additional Feature:Premium non-toxic nonstick coating
   • Additional Feature:4.4 star customer ratings

5. SafBbcue Full Size Griddle Inserts for Kenmore

   [affimg asin=”B0DJWYLH1Y” size=”large”]

   Best Kenmore Fit

   View Latest Price

   If you’re looking to expand your Kenmore grill’s cooking versatility without replacing the entire unit, SafBbcue’s Full Size Griddle Inserts offer an ideal solution. This 16.4 x 24-inch griddle features high-quality carbon steel construction with a 4mm thickness that guarantees even heat distribution and faster preheating than traditional griddles. The nonstick surface makes cleanup effortless, while ergonomic handles allow you to move it safely. Installation is straightforward—simply remove your existing grates and replace them with the griddle insert. Compatible with numerous Kenmore 4-burner models, it’s perfect for year-round cooking, whether you’re grilling outdoors in summer or cooking indoors during colder months.

   • Material Type:Carbon steel with nonstick coating
   • Cooking Surface Design:Full-size flat griddle insert
   • Dimensions:24 x 16.4 inches
   • Heat Distribution:4mm thickness ensures even heat distribution
   • Portability Features:Ergonomic handles for easy movement
   • Cleaning & Maintenance:Nonstick coating for fast cleanup
   • Additional Feature:Specifically designed Kenmore compatibility
   • Additional Feature:4mm carbon steel thickness
   • Additional Feature:Faster heat up time

6. Lodge Pro-Grid Reversible Cast Iron Grill/Griddle

   [affimg asin=”B00008GKDQ” size=”large”]

   Best All-Purpose Cooker

   View Latest Price

   Those seeking a versatile cooking surface that’ll outlast their Kenmore grill should consider Lodge’s Pro-Grid Reversible Cast Iron Grill/Griddle. This 20 x 10.44 inch cast iron powerhouse features a reversible design—grill on one side, flat griddle on the other—giving you flexibility for searing, sautéing, pancakes, and burgers. Made in the USA by a family-owned company since 1896, it’s PFAS-free and naturally seasoned without chemicals. The griddle spans two stovetop burners, works on all cooktops including induction, and handles oven, grill, and campfire cooking. You’ll appreciate how it improves with use, building seasoning over time. This durable investment pays dividends across generations of cooking adventures.

   • Material Type:Naturally seasoned cast iron
   • Cooking Surface Design:Reversible (flat griddle and grill)
   • Dimensions:20 x 10.44 inches
   • Heat Distribution:Durable construction for consistent heating
   • Portability Features:No built-in handles (cast iron style)
   • Cleaning & Maintenance:Seasoned cast iron improves with use
   • Additional Feature:PFAS-free chemical-free surface
   • Additional Feature:Spans two stovetop burners
   • Additional Feature:Improves with continued use

7. Utheer Nonstick Cooking Griddle for Gas Grills

   [affimg asin=”B09Z6JCGQC” size=”large”]

   Budget-Friendly Pick

   View Latest Price

   The 17″ x 13″ nonstick surface won’t stick to your breakfast, lunch, or dinner—making this griddle ideal for anyone who values hassle-free cooking. You’ll appreciate the heavy-duty metal construction that resists deformation and heat damage. Detachable side handles give you flexibility when positioning the griddle on your Kenmore gas grill, while the integrated grease trough minimizes flare-ups for safer cooking. The polished edges protect your hands from scratches. You can cook everything from eggs and pancakes to steaks and quesadillas. To prevent sticking, heat the griddle first, add oil, then place your food. Cleanup’s effortless thanks to the nonstick coating, making this versatile griddle perfect for camping, tailgating, or backyard entertaining.

   • Material Type:Nonstick coated metal
   • Cooking Surface Design:Flat griddle with grease trough
   • Dimensions:17 x 13 inches
   • Heat Distribution:Heavy duty, heat resistant construction
   • Portability Features:Detachable side handles
   • Cleaning & Maintenance:Easy-clean nonstick coating
   • Additional Feature:Heavy duty heat resistant metal
   • Additional Feature:Grease trough prevents flare-ups
   • Additional Feature:Thicker material prevents deformation

Factors to Consider When Choosing a Griddle for Kenmore Gas Grill

When you’re selecting a griddle for your Kenmore gas grill, you’ll want to verify it’s compatible with your specific model and consider the cooking surface size that fits your needs. Material quality directly impacts durability and performance, so you should prioritize griddles that distribute heat evenly across the entire cooking surface. Finally, opt for a griddle that’s easy to clean and maintain, ensuring you can keep it in top condition for years to come.

Compatibility With Kenmore

Before you invest in a griddle, you’ll want to verify that it’ll fit your specific Kenmore model, since grill dimensions vary considerably across their product line. Check your grill’s measurements and compare them against the griddle’s specifications to ascertain proper fit.

You should also examine your grill’s cooking grates and burner configuration. Some griddles require specific spacing between burners for even heat distribution, while others need particular grate designs for stability.

Review Kenmore’s official documentation or contact their customer service to confirm compatibility. Some aftermarket griddles work universally, but others are model-specific. Confirm that the griddle won’t obstruct ventilation or create safety hazards. Finally, check whether your warranty covers aftermarket accessories, as using incompatible griddles might void coverage.

Cooking Surface Size

Selecting the right cooking surface size is critical to maximizing your griddle’s performance on your Kenmore gas grill. You’ll want to match your griddle dimensions to your available grill space for efficient, even heating across the entire cooking surface.

A larger cooking area lets you prepare multiple food items simultaneously, boosting your cooking efficiency. Before purchasing, measure your grill grates to determine the maximum griddle size your model can accommodate without compromising functionality or causing overhang.

Consider your Kenmore’s burner count as well. Aligning your griddle size with the number of burners guarantees full coverage and ideal heat distribution. Taking these measurements prevents compatibility issues and ensures you’re selecting a griddle that truly complements your grill’s capabilities.

Material Quality Matters

Now that you’ve determined the right size for your Kenmore gas grill, you’ll want to focus on the material itself—that’s where the real performance difference shows. Cast iron griddles deliver exceptional heat distribution and retention, ensuring consistent cooking results, though they require regular seasoning to maintain their natural nonstick surface. Stainless steel options offer durability and rust resistance, but may sacrifice even heating compared to cast iron. Heavy-duty materials resist warping when exposed to high gas grill temperatures, protecting your investment long-term. While nonstick coatings simplify cleanup and food release, they deteriorate over time with regular use. Consider your priorities: cast iron demands more maintenance but improves with age, while stainless steel requires less upkeep with slightly compromised performance.

Heat Distribution Evenness

Consistency in cooking hinges on how evenly your griddle heats across its entire surface. You’ll want to prioritize cast iron griddles, which distribute heat far more effectively than thinner metal alternatives. The thickness and material composition directly impact how uniformly your griddle heats up and maintains temperature throughout cooking.

Look for griddles featuring reinforced ridges or supports that promote even heat flow and prevent warping under high temperatures. Some designs incorporate hollowed-out or vented sections that facilitate more uniform airflow, enhancing heating consistency. These structural features aren’t merely cosmetic—they’re essential for eliminating hot spots that compromise your cooking results.

Ease Of Cleaning

After you’ve invested in a quality griddle, keeping it clean shouldn’t require a second job. You’ll find that nonstick surfaces dramatically simplify cleanup compared to bare metal alternatives. Look for griddles featuring built-in grease troughs or grooves that channel drippings away, reducing mess and effort. Removable or detachable handles give you complete access to the cooking surface, eliminating awkward angles during cleaning. Smooth, polished edge designs prevent food and debris from accumulating in crevices. Keep in mind that cast iron griddles demand ongoing maintenance to preserve their seasoned coating, whereas nonstick options require minimal upkeep. By prioritizing these cleaning-friendly features, you’ll maintain your Kenmore griddle’s performance and appearance with minimal hassle.

Durability And Longevity

When you’re selecting a griddle for your Kenmore gas grill, durability should rank among your top priorities. Cast iron griddles offer exceptional longevity, often lasting generations with proper maintenance. Their well-seasoned surfaces provide reliable nonstick performance that outlasts synthetic coatings, which inevitably wear down over time.

Thicker materials like heavy-duty cast iron and steel resist warping and deformation from intense heat exposure. Griddles featuring reinforced support structures and thick bases distribute heat evenly, preventing hot spots that cause cracking and warping over extended use.

Your maintenance habits tremendously impact longevity. Implement proper cleaning and storage techniques to keep your griddle functional for years. By investing in a quality, durable griddle and caring for it consistently, you’ll maximize its lifespan and cooking performance.

Price And Value

While durability guarantees your griddle lasts for years, the initial investment and overall value proposition matter just as much. You’ll want to calculate the cost per square inch of cooking surface to compare options fairly. Look for griddles offering substantial cooking area without breaking your budget—this maximizes your return on investment.

Don’t overlook additional features either. Non-stick coatings and grease management systems enhance functionality and simplify cleanup, adding real value beyond the base price. Take time to shop around across multiple retailers and online platforms. You’ll often find significant price variations for identical models, so comparing options verifies you’re getting the best deal possible on a quality griddle that truly serves your cooking needs.